Online ordering powered by SeamlessWeb
2728 Broadway (104th & Broadway)(212) 932-1000
$15.00 delivery minimum.
Delivery estimate is 30 - 45 min. More info
SeamlessWeb allows you to enjoy convenient online ordering from the best local restaurants. If you're ordering for the first time, start your order by entering your address to the right. Return users log in here.
Minimum order of $15.00 is required for delivery.
Print this menu
Available Monday through Friday from 12:00pm - 4:00pm.
Half calzone, half personal pizza.
Look no further than Angelina Pizzabar! They’re serving up the best in authentic New York style pizzas, Italian pastas and subs. They have all the Italian cuisine that you’re craving, from the classics to specialties, all right here in the New York area. And just when you thought you were stuffed, they’ve got desserts that will knock your socks off! Stop on in or order online for delivery today.
Nonna Pizza—Mushrooms, artichoke, aged Parmigiano and fresh parsley
Mexicana—Chorizo sausage, roasted peppers, chipotle and cilantro
Eggplant Parmigiano—Sicilian eggplant, Parmigiano, tomato and fresh thyme
Prosciutto—Prosciutto, Provolone, salami, Roma tomato and fresh basil
Bianco Forte— Garlic, Ricotta, Mozzarella, spicy sausage and hot peppers
Verde—Baby spinach, garlic, Arugula, Mozzarella drizzled with balsamic vinegar and oil
I wanted to like this place based on the menu. I really did. But when we ordered at 7:55pm on a Sunday night and our pizza still wasn't here an hour later (the window was 30-45 minutes), I called the restaurant, only to be met with rudeness and excuses about waiting for a deliveryman on the other end of the line. The attitude I got was definitely uncooperative, and the woman who answered the phone could not even give me a revised estimate of when the food would arrive. Our pizza was ok, but the delivery problems made ordering from here a bummer.
Posted 2 days ago by Karin V.
I've always been pleased with the pizza. Always been warm. Sometimes it's taken a little long for delivery, but nothing terrible.
Posted 3 months ago by T Jason M.
Ordered a pizza at 7:30pm on a Saturday night and it got here pretty quickly (15 mins?) for that time of the evening. That being said, they didn't send me an email saying that they'd gotten my order, so I was about to call them when they showed up - definitely took me by surprise. Pizza was good enough, but a bit on the cold side...
Posted 3 months ago by Nabila P.
Delivery was slow. I called, and the food left past the end of the delivery window
Posted 3 months ago by Alexa P.
Love the restaurant -- not for delivery. The pizza was cold and beat up. The salad was also not the standard which I have come to expect in the restaurant. I'll continue to go to Angelina's, but I can't imagine getting delivery from there again.
Posted 4 months ago by James F.
Pizza was excellent and delivery was fast!
Posted 4 months ago by DENNIS P.
I live around the corner, and angelinas is the go to pizza place for my girlfriend and I. The meatball is by far the best choice on the menu
Posted 5 months ago by Brian S.
Unlike other reviews, our delivery came fast - and on a night with snow - so we were very happy there. The traditional crust is a bit much (too chewy) but the pizza flavors were very good. I'd prefer a touch more sauce, probably because the crust was so chewy, but overall a decent meal.
Posted 6 months ago by Jared S.
Agree on zero stars. the pizza is just awful. and overpriced. and cold upon delivery. and the manager, Peter, was rude about complaints. agree with other reviewers: SKIP.
Posted 6 months ago by Carla E.
took forever, too expensive for what you get
Posted 7 months ago by Eve B.
The pizza came partially stuck to the box, was not that interesting, and was overpriced.
Posted 7 months ago by Robert A.
meh meh meh ... mediocre to subpar at best. SKIP!
Posted 8 months ago by Morgan D.
good pizza
Posted 8 months ago by Jacob G.
Delivery took close to an hour. I'm on the UWS and the delivery guy went to the UES.
Posted 8 months ago by Zinovia S.
Can I give it zero stars? I want to give it Zero stars. I had read the reviews, but decided that since the pizza sounded so good I would brave it and that maybe they were going to be better this week. First, I ordered early (5:30) so that I would beat the rush. It took about 1 hour 15 to get my food. My confirmation email listed my wait as approx 30 minutes, and I don't live THAT far away. Second, my food came ICE cold. Like below room temperature cold. Good for the Pellagrino I ordered, bad for my pizza. Third, the pizza. I got the Tartufina Pizza, it sounded so good. It was SO BAD. Even when I reheated it, it was soggy and gross. The arugula on top was sickly and yellow, the mushrooms were in the form of a paste, no truffle oil (that I could detect) and like 4 sun dried tomatoes. The cheese was plastic-y and gross, the sauce DID taste like the stuff from the jar. The crust was great in the places it wasn't completely soggy. I also got the bruschetta. The tomato chunks were so HUGE they needed to be cut with a knife. um. I ordered in so I wouldn't have to chop things. thanks. Also, the red onion pieces were really big and really spicy (and I love red onion). Also, the tomatoes were a bit mealy. On the bright side my large Pellegrino was $3 and it was delightful.
Posted 8 months ago by KERRY H.
Really ? 1 hour wait for a cold pizza (not coldish but COLD) and a disgusting Cheese cake which apparently got dismembered during the trip ! I don't get it. This is not the first time I order there but this is the first time they got everything wrong ! Oh and the pizza was not even good.
Posted 8 months ago by Frederic P.
The food was OK, but it took over an hour to get here!
Posted 8 months ago by Kristin H.
Service was very quick, but every item in the order had way too much garlic or onion.
Posted 9 months ago by Tanya C.
The food was cold when it arrived. The pizza had slid to one side of the box and folded over on itself. It was basically inedible. I will never order from this place again.
Posted 9 months ago by Sarah S.
Just, plain bad pizza. I could just as well have made one in the microwave
Posted 9 months ago by Asgeir G.
I had one good experience with this place, but was VERY disappointed when I ordered the meatball pizza and it was disgusting. The meatballs weren't sliced, but rather they just plopped one whole meatball on each slice. The cheese was gross. Ended up eating half a slice and throwing the rest away. I will not order from them again.
Posted 10 months ago by Daniel P.
The perfect margherita pizza - crust is super thin, fresh ingradients and really tasty. The only problem is you can eat a whole one and will want to. It was totally worth it. Great pizza.
Posted 10 months ago by Karen D.
The food gets five stars. New king of UWS pizza on seamlessweb, no doubt. Unfortunately, it is almost always delivered lukewarm. They lose a star for that.
Posted 10 months ago by Terri H.
Excellent pizza but not as crisp on delivery as in the restaurant.
Posted 10 months ago by David L.
good pizza delivery was great once and came late another time and was a little cold but for good brick oven pizza i will order again
Posted 11 months ago by john v.
Great ingredients . fresh. But Pizza arrived a bit soggy. A little crisper and it gets the star
Posted 11 months ago by Greg P.
Great Pizza! I mean really great! Menu could use some work, but they're brand new on Seamless
Posted 11 months ago by Carter E.
....there is no menu or ability to order from this restaurant here...which by default means that it should be rated as no stars, for the purpose of this site...?
Posted 11 months ago by Sarah R.
Absolutely awful. Delivery was incorrect. Pizza was smashed against box.
Posted 11 months ago by Sam S.
Seriously chewy "traditional" crust.
Posted a year ago by Francesca R.
Only select user reviews are published on SeamlessWeb. All user-submitted ratings contribute to Angelina Pizza Bar's overall SeamlessWeb rating, but we manually screen all reviews and only publish those that are relevant and helpful. Tips for getting your review published »
Above content provided by restaurant.
Order online from Angelina Pizza Bar by entering your address below. Online ordering powered by SeamlessWeb.com.
Return users log in here.
Click a menu item to add it to your order.
Back to top